Followers

Thursday, April 21, 2022

Why remembering unsung Dalit women heroes matters

 It would be a profound injustice to recognise Babasaheb Ambedkar, whose 131st birth anniversary was recently celebrated, as only a Dalit leader. He also worked hard for the cause of women’s rights, believing that a society’s political, economic and social aspects can only be ameliorated when men and women have equal rights. This piece is therefore a tribute to all the women from the periphery who have either not been heard of or written about but are important. We can’t celebrate Ambedkar without giving due respect and acknowledgement to these women.

The historical and cultural narratives of India have failed to acknowledge the contributions of the women from the margins, as they are either androcentric in approach or reflective of the dominant castes. Remembering unsung Dalit women heroes and their stories of struggle and bravery from across the centuries, will broaden these narratives and help address the institutionalised discrimination Dalit women have faced for centuries.

The story of Sabari from the Ramayana has been used as an example of acceptance, selflessness and unconditional love, and adapted into bhajans and poems. The coming of bhakti saw the emergence of women from the Mahar caste, such as Sant Nirmala and Soyarabai, questioning Hindu orthodoxy. Nangeli fought against the cruel “breast tax” system, which imposed a tax on women of the lower castes who covered their breasts. She cut off one of her breasts and presented it to tax collectors, inspiring other women in the community to cover their breasts unapologetically.

Every section of society attempted to combine social and political liberation during the freedom struggle. Kuyili, who commanded the army of Velu Nachiyar, the queen of Sivaganga in Tamil Nadu, was a Dalit woman who fought against the British around 1780. Jhalkaribai, another fearless Dalit warrior, played a pivotal role in what is known as the First War of Independence in 1857, as the most trusted companion and advisor of Rani Laxmibai of Jhansi. Born in Ujirao, Lucknow, Uda Devi formed a battalion consisting of Dalit women under the leadership of Begum Hazrat Mahal.

Among social reformers, there was Savitribai Phule, a pioneer in education for Dalits, who started a school in 1848 with nine girls. By 1851 this became three schools with around 150 girl students. She also started a school in 1849 with her friend Fatima Sheikh, the Mahila Seva Mandal in 1852 to raise awareness about women’s rights and the Balahatya Pratibandhak Griha, where widows and rape survivors could deliver their babies. Born in the Kaibarta caste community, Rani Rashmoni, protested practices like sati and child marriage and atrocities against lower caste people and even submitted a plea against polygamy to the Company. Moovalur Ramamirtham Ammaiyar fought against the exploitative Devadasi system. In 1936, she published a Tamil novel on Devadasis and wrote the fictional series Damayanthi in 1945.

Dakshayani Velayudhan was the first and only Dalit woman to be elected to the constituent assembly in 1946. She was also a part of the provisional parliament from 1946-1952. Her contribution in civil disobedience and satyagraha is a story that needs to be told.

The bravery of Dalit women has not only been visible in their deeds but also in the words they wrote. In Maharashtra, writers like Shantabai Kamble, Mallika Amar Sheikh and Kumud Pawde shone a light on Dalit feminism through their autobiographies. In Tamil Nadu, writers like Bama and P Sivakami explored gender discrimination as a two-fold oppression. Marathi writers like Urmila Pawar and Meenakshi Moon worked to make Dalit women visible in women’s movement and, through their research and testimonies, brought out the grim reality of the missing voices. Dalit women like Dulari Devi and Mayawati also need to be celebrated. Her conviction and social engineering skills made Mayawati chief minister of UP four times, and through her art, Devi, a Mithila painter from Bihar, tracks the interplay between meaning and power within the hierarchical structures of religion, caste, gender and politics.

Written by Aditi Narayani Paswan

Source: Indian Express, 21/04/22

Face the facts on communal violence in India

 Hate and bigotry feed on each other. They germinate and flourish on a toxic diet of divisive and schismatic ideologies and polarising creeds that discriminate against human beings on the basis of colour, region, gender, faith — and divide them between believers and non-believers — ranging the chosen ones against the idolatrous.

Calling out hate’ by S Y Quraishi (IE, April 15) has little to do with the anatomy of hate or its ongoing malignancy. It is more of an ad hominem attack on the ruling dispensation. A complex phenomenon has been over-simplified to suit a convenient political narrative. The arguments are drearily familiar, facts dodgy and conclusions delusional.

For aeons, India has had syncretic traditions inspired by the Vedic aphorism, “Ekam sad vipra bahudha vadanti” (there is only one truth and learned persons call it by many names). Because of this underpinning, Indian society has never insisted on uniformity in any facet of life. Indian philosophy is a smorgasbord of varied ideas and traditions — incongruous at times, but always a part of a harmonious milieu.

This equanimity of Indian society was, however, disrupted by invading creeds claiming only their God, and His messenger were true, and the rest were false and worthy of destruction, along with their followers and places of worship.

The first such incursion came in 712, when Muhammad bin Qasim vanquished Sindh, and as Chach Nama, a contemporary Arab chronicle states, introduced the practice of treating local Hindus as zimmis, forcing them to pay jizya (a poll tax), as a penalty to live by their beliefs. “Hate” and “bigotry” thus made their debut in India, which was hitherto free from this virus. Pakistan’s official website credits this invasion as when the country was born as an Islamic nation in the Subcontinent.

In the 11th century, Mahmud of Ghazni, while receiving the caliphate honours on his accession to the throne, took a vow to wage jihad every year against Indian idolaters. During his 32-year reign, he did keep his solemn promise over a dozen times. The rest is history.

But why go into the distant past? Unfortunately, the trail of hate unleashed over a thousand years ago continues to haunt us even today. The last 100-odd years witnessed the Moplah riots, Partition, and the decimation of Hindus/Sikhs/Buddhists in Afghanistan, Pakistan, Bangladesh and the Kashmir Valley. The recent pre-planned attacks on Ram Navami processions in over half a dozen states, and the onslaught on the Hanuman Janamutsav rally have reminded us that the ogre of hate is alive and stinging.

It’s uncanny: While communal mayhem was going on in India, Muslim mobs were fighting pitched battles against the police in dozens of towns in Spain, Sweden and the city of Jerusalem. In Sweden, Muslims were agitated over blasphemy involving the holy Quran. Protests in Spain are against the imprisonment of a rapper convicted of insulting the monarchy and praising terrorist violence. While the issues involving these sordid episodes may differ, the pattern is common.

Were the Hindu-Muslim relations peaceful in the past and have soured post-2014? The fact is, ties between the two communities were seldom cordial. There were intermittent skirmishes, wars and occasional short-lived opportunistic alliances. Is the current dispensation responsible for Muslim alienation? Remember, even Gandhiji failed to wean Muslims from Muhammad Ali Jinnah’s schismatic movement.

In the aftermath of the Moplah violence and communal riots at several places in India, Gandhiji observed in Young India (May 24, 1924): “My own experience but confirms the opinion that the Musalman as a rule is a bully, and the Hindu as a rule is a coward”. Nothing much has since changed in the Subcontinent.

Can laws or police fight hate? No. If they could, Kashmiri Hindus wouldn’t have gone through the hell they did in the 1990s, and would have been happily back in their homes by now. India is a secular democracy, not because of its Constitution. It’s the other way round. When Pakistan declared itself an Islamic Republic in 1947, it would have been natural for India to identify itself as a Hindu state. It didn’t, and couldn’t have — because of its Hindu ethos of pluralism. A Hindu-dominated India, is, and will always be, catholic, plural, myriad and a vibrant democracy.

George Orwell said, “The relative freedom which we enjoy depends on public opinion. The law is no protection. Governments make laws, but whether they are carried out, and how the police behave, depends on the general temper in the country”.

Can one fight hate selectively? The burning of Graham Staines and his children is reprehensible. So was the lynching of Akhlaq and Junaid. But why the cowering silence on the dastardly gunning down of Swami Lakshmanananda Saraswati and four of his disciples (August 2008) in Orissa for which seven Christians and a Maoist have been convicted? Over a dozen Muslim workers of the BJP have been killed in Jammu & Kashmir and other parts of India in the recent past. These victims of hate are, of course, ignored. Their deaths don’t suit the narrative.

Charged reactions, punctuated with half-truths, deliberate omissions and tailored narratives, offer no real solution. Pusillanimity to face facts will only exacerbate the situation and give egregious results. Ignorance is not always bliss.

In this context, it’s relevant to recall what Lester Pearson (14th PM of Canada) said: “Misunderstanding arising from ignorance breeds fear, and fear remains the greatest enemy of peace.”


Written by Balbir Punj

Source: Indian Express, 21/04/22


Wednesday, April 20, 2022

Quote of the Day April 20, 2022

 

“If you want your child to walk the righteous path, do not merely point the way; lead the way.”
J A Rosenkranz
“यदि आप चाहते हैं कि आपका बच्चा सही मार्ग पर चले, तो केवल उसे सही मार्ग की जानकारी प्रदान न करें, बल्कि उस पर चल कर भी दिखाएं।”
जे ए रोसेनक्रांज

India’s policy on cooperation is key to creating livelihoods for all

 A two-day national conference on India’s Cooperation Policy inaugurated by the home and cooperation minister took place earlier this week. The programme was attended by several officials of the Centre and states along with other national institutes and cooperatives. Marked by characteristic incisiveness, the pith of the minister’s address was a call to usher-in a ‘movement for cooperation’. Bureaucrats were quick to draw up the achievements of their respective departments of cooperation—in a manner that showed their preparation for the mandate of the policy. Albeit useful, this missed a major point: that cooperation is not an end in itself. Cooperation is an approach, or, as the draft National Policy on Cooperatives puts it, “a preferred instrument of execution of public policy especially in rural areas". And fundamental to this approach are the attributes that describe our society in general but are amplified in the context of Indian villages. These are the attributes of community ties, collective decision making, mutual trust, shared ownership and social responsibility.

After 74 years of independence and an array of schemes to meet the basic needs of citizens, it is only a matter of logical progression that the state should now focus on creating a society of self-dependent people with adequate livelihood opportunities. And cooperation is being seen as key to this transition. From farming and food-processing to fisheries and self-help groups (SHGs); cooperatives are touted as catalysts for social and economic progress. But what does this renewed focus mean for the effectiveness of a policy? This article picks up elements of cooperation from a scheme aimed at enhancing the livelihood of forest-dependent Tribal communities to answer this question. Rolled out in 2018, the Pradhan Mantri Van Dhan Yojana (PMVDY) leverages the traditional knowledge of Tribal communities to harvest forest produce and strengthen their market linkages. Central to its operations is a Van Dhan Vikas Kendra (VDVK). It is a Tribal-owned centre that undertakes aggregation, processing and packaging of forest produce for sale. The functioning of the scheme hinges on the attributes of cooperative existence.

The first step in cooperation is to bear in mind the affinity among members while setting up VDVKs. With mutual trust and a certain degree of affiliation among members, VDVKs can survive the initial cycles of loss and may continue to exist even after the state pulls out support.

A promising demonstration of this is seen in the Gadchiroli district of Maharashtra, where a group of 200 women have created a market for neem pesticides with their coordinated action. These women lost their first batch of produce to the rains. Starting out slow, they manufactured pesticides and used them in their own farms initially. Promising results prompted much buy-in from others. Today, all the farmer groups in the area buy this organic pesticide from that VDVK.

In yet another VDVK, in Jharkhand, the women said that they were amazed to see the quantum of forest produce that they collectively procured. Earlier, they would sell these products individually and make do with prices fixed by their buyers. As they have started aggregating products now, their negotiating power has also increased. “The traders now come to us to buy mahua flowers, karanj and imli instead of us having to go to them," exclaimed the president of the kendra.

Cooperation also entails convergence. In some VDVKs in Odisha and Chhattisgarh, training for beneficiaries is being conducted in convergence with other schemes like the Entrepreneurship and Skill Development Programme or the Samarth Yojana. As beneficiaries bring home more money, their social standing also improves, reckon women in Kondagaon district of Chhattisgarh. “My husband would not let me participate in the SHG meetings earlier but now drops me off at the kendra every day at 9am," one of them said.

Finally, the autonomy of these cooperatives, which finds mention in the draft policy, is critical to their survival. In the case of VDVKs, the community is free to procure non-timber forest produce for sale. Communities that have control over forests also understand the limitations and requirements of sustainable harvesting. Without community-based forest rights, the sustenance of the scheme would be jeopardized. Recognizing this, Odisha held several meetings of forest officials with community members right at the planning stage, so as to ensure their support later on.

The PMVDY offers a classic example of how the cooperative spirit can be harnessed for social fulfilment and economic growth. This is not to say that cooperatives are not susceptible to failure, inefficiency or corruption. But the multiplier effect created by the success of a few kendras in terms of families empowered and forests preserved would offset the cost of failure of many others. And with enough successful kendras, a cleaner, rule-based and more efficient system would eventually develop. It is yet to be seen how India’s cooperation policy is eventually realized in practice. But schemes such as the PMVDY show that it does offer hope and merits our attention.

Sakshi Abrol is a policy manager at Nation First Policy Research Centre

Source: Mintepaper, 19/04/22

Current Affairs-April 19, 2022

 

INDIA

– Lt Gen Manoj Pande becomes first engineer to be appointed Army chief

– Gujarat: PM visits Command & Control Centre for Schools (Vidhya Samiksha Kendra) in Gandhinagar

– President Ram Nath Kovind inaugurates Diamond Jubilee celebrations of India International Centre (IIC) in New Delhi

– National Security Adviser (NSA) Ajit Doval inaugurates 10-days National Cyber Security Incident Response Exercise in New Delhi

– India, Finland announce decision to establish Indo-Finnish Virtual Network Centre on Quantum Computing

– Mauritius PM Pravind Kumar Jugnauth arrives on 8-day visit to India

– India assures Mongolia of help in space, telecom and energy sectors

– Legendary Odia singer and music director Prafulla Kar dies at 83

ECONOMY & CORPORATE

– World Bank report says extreme poverty in India declines 12.3% during 2011-2019

– WPI inflation hits 4-month high of 14.55% in March as crude, commodity prices spike

– Enforcement Directorate (ED) attaches assets worth over Rs 757 cr of Amway India Enterprises Private Ltd; company accused of running a multi-level marketing scam

WORLD

– World Bank cuts its global growth forecast for 2022 from 3.2% from 4.1%,

– Google launches ‘Switch to Android’ app allowing Apple users to move their data from iPhone to Android

– World Heritage Day celebrated on April 18, theme: ‘Heritage and Climate’

SPORTS

– India finish third in Asia-Oceania Billie Jean King Cup women’s tennis tournament in Antalya, Turkey

– Haryana defeats Tamil Nadu in final to win Hockey India Senior Men’s National Championships in Bhopal

Current Affairs-April 20, 2022

 

INDIA

– IAF successfully test-fires BrahMos missile from Su30-MkI fighter jet

– Indian and foreign higher education institutions can offer joint or dual degrees: UGC

– Gujarat: PM lays foundation stone of WHO Global Centre for Traditional Medicine in Jamnagar

ECONOMY & CORPORATE

– IMF slashes India’s 2022-23 GDP growth forecast to 8.2% from 9% earlier in its World Economic Outlook report

– Govt sets foodgrain output target at 328 million tonnes for 2022-23 crop year (July-June)

– RBI caps lending limits of NBFCs to bring them on a par with those of banks

– India’s first portable solar rooftop system inaugurated at Swaminarayan Akshardham temple complex in Gandhinagar

WORLD

– Finance minister Nirmala Sitharaman meets International Monetary Fund (IMF) managing director Kristalina Georgieva during annual spring meetings of IMF and the World Bank in Washington

– Lok Sabha Speaker Om Birla arrives in Hanoi, Vietnam on a three-day visit

– Citing Russia’s war, IMF cuts global growth forecast for 2022 to 3.6% from 4.4% made in January

– Russia seizes Kreminna, a town in Donbas region in eastern Ukraine

– South Africa: President Cyril Ramaphosa declares ‘national state of disaster’ over floods

– US Vice President Kamala Harris announces decision to ban US anti-satellite weapons tests

– World Liver Day observed on April 19

World Heritage Day

 On the 18th of April every year, World Heritage Day is celebrated across the world. This day is also known as the International Day for Monuments and Sites.

Overview:

  • This day is observed to generate awareness about the importance of Heritage.
  • This day also promotes ways to preserve and protect heritage across the world.

The theme of World Heritage Day 2022

The theme for this year’s World Heritage Day is ‘Heritage and Climate’. The theme of this year promotes heritage conservation practices and research with the aim of delivering pathways that are climate-resilient to strengthen sustainable development while advocating for low-carbon futures.

History of this day

In the year 1982, International Council on Monuments and Sites (ICOMOS) first floated the idea of observing International Day for Monuments and Sites with the aim of promoting awareness about cultural heritage, their vulnerability and the efforts that are required for their conservation. Later the United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization (UNESCO) in its 22nd General Conference in 1983 adopted the resolution. Since then, this day has been observed annually across the world.

About World Heritage Sites that are present in India

In India, there are a total of 3691 sites and monuments. 40 among those have been designated as UNESCO World Heritage Sites. Some of the designated sites are the Ajanta Caves, Taj Mahal, and Ellora Caves. Natural sites like the Kaziranga National Park in Assam has also been included among World Heritage Sites.