Followers

Monday, April 07, 2025

The season’s hunt is on

 

Sikar Utsav, while culturally significant to some, presents a grave threat to the wildlife and the ecosystems of Southwest Bengal. The solution lies in a collective effort from all sectors of society



Human history reveals a story of fascinating evolution, with mankind transitioning from the life of a hunter-gatherer to that of a modern, technologically-advanced society. However, this progress has not been uniform. There are still places where the influence of modernity has not reached its full potential.

In India, the conservation of forests and wildlife has been a constant challenge despite the passage of laws and the establishment of several protective measures. The enactment of the Wildlife (Protection) Act of 1972 marked a critical turning point in conservation efforts. However, despite the best intentions, the implementation of this law has never been flawless. The illegal killing of wildlife has declined but it has not been eradicated.

Protecting forests and wildlife is not just the responsibility of a select few. It is enshrined in Article 51A of the Indian Constitution that makes it a fundamental duty for every citizen to protect and improve the natural environment while promoting compassion for all living creatures.

Among Indian states, West Bengal has long been a forerunner in conservation, often setting an example for the rest of the country to follow. One notable innovation that emerged in the late 1980s was the Joint Forest Management Committees, initiated particularly around the Arabari area in West Midnapore district. This pioneering model of forest management encouraged the involvement of local communities, particularly those who were heavily dependent on the forests for their livelihoods. Spearheaded by Ajit Kr Banerjee and a dedicated team of foresters, this initiative shifted the relationship between local villagers and forests from one of exploitation to cooperation.

The JFMC model worked by incorporating the villagers into forest protection and management efforts. In exchange for their active involvement, the government offered financial incentives and rewards, such as a share in the revenue generated from forest operations. For instance, up to 40% of the monetary benefits from forestry operations were distributed among members of the JFMCs. This amounted to approximately 50 crore rupees annually for the southwestern districts of Purulia, Bankura, Jhargram, West Midnapore, Birbhum and Burdwan. This shared benefit model helped improve the forest cover in Southwest Bengal and fostered a harmonious relationship between the local communities and the forests.

Consequently, the forest cover in Southwest Bengal has improved significantly and there has been a notable increase in biodiversity. Local wildlife populations have rebounded and species such as the Rusty Spotted Cat, a rare and elusive animal, have been spotted again. Additionally, the presence of apex predators, such as tigers, is now more commonly reported in the region. These tangible improvements are a direct result of the people-forest movement, which fostered a sense of peace and prosperity through cooperation and mutual benefit.

Despite these successes, South­west Bengal continues to face significant challenges related to wildlife protection. One such challenge is the Sikar Utsav, a regional festival that celebrates the hunting tradition, which has historically been tied to the socio-cultural fabric of the region. The festival, held during the dry season (from March to May), coincides with the peak period of forest fires, making it even more damaging to the environment.

During this time, some local villagers, along with people from neighboring districts and even at times from neighbouring states like Jharkhand, Odisha, and Bihar, enter the forests to hunt wild boars, wild hares, and other small species. This tradition, although deeply rooted in the regional culture, results in significant damage to the region’s wildlife and adds tremendous pressure on the already under-resourced forest authorities.

The forests of Southwest Bengal are vast, open, and easily accessible with human settlements often intermingled with the forest areas. While many villagers use the forests in an ecologically sustainable manner, others exploit the resources for personal gain. The forest department, with its limited manpower, finds it difficult to guard such a vast and interconnected ecosystem. Forest staff in the field are overwhelmed by the sheer number of hunters during the Sikar Utsav. As a result, efforts to stop this destructive activity are often thwarted and the forest staff are unable to fully enforce conservation regulations.

The practice of hunting during the Sikar Utsav is often justified because of its cultural significance. Many of those involved in these hunts view the event as a traditional celebration that has been passed down through generations. However, the adverse consequences of these actions on biodiversity and the environment are undeniable.

While it is crucial to respect cultural traditions, there is an urgent need for awareness and change. The environment and the wildlife face unprecedented threats from overexploitation and human encroachment. The actions taken today will directly affect future generations, potentially leaving them with a world devoid of the biodiversity we now take for granted.

There is no time to waste when it comes to protecting the planet’s ecosystems. The current trajectory of environmental degradation, fuelled by human activities, could lead to the extinction of many species. This stark reality should be a wake-up call for all.

The effort to restore forest vegetation and wildlife diversity in this terrain through participatory forest management has been substantial, taking nearly three decades to witness the return of high-quality vegetation alongside its native wildlife species. The need for cooperation among local communities, government authorities, environmental organisations, and other stakeholders is greater than ever. The JFMC model has shown that people can play a positive role in forest conservation. But this model needs to be expanded and strengthened. We must invest more time and energy in awareness campaigns, law enforcement, forest protection, and strengthening infrastructure to prevent destructive practices such as the Sikar Utsav.

There must be a concerted effort to engage with local communities and educate them about the long-term benefits of sustainable living and the importance of preserving biodiversity. The narrative needs to shift from one of exploitation to one of coexistence. This can only happen through dialogue, education, and the active involvement of all stakeholders.

Sikar Utsav, while culturally significant to some, presents a grave threat to the wildlife and the ecosystems of Southwest Bengal. The solution lies in a collective effort from all sectors of society — local communities, government agencies, environmental groups, and the public — to promote sustainable practices, protect natural habitats, and preserve the biodiversity that is an essential part of our heritage.

Singaram Kulandaivel 

Source: The Telegraph, 5/04/25

Green murder: Editorial on India’s dwindling forests

 

The executive must rectify this predation on precious forested land. But such interventions are contingent upon sustained public pressure, which remains as fractured as India’s forests


Data submitted by the Union government have revealed a distressing picture of India’s forest lands. According to the report presented to the National Green Tribunal, more than 13,000 square kilometres of forest areas are under encroachment across 25 states and Union territories. It must be pointed out in this context that the findings of the latest India State of Forest Report had also drawn attention to the negative growth in forested areas in some states. Forest area refers to land officially designated as forest. Astonishingly, the encroached area is more than the total geographical area of Delhi, Sikkim and Goa put together. The ministry of environment, forest and climate change was prodded to submit the report by the NGT, which was forced to take suo motu cognisance of a government report released last year that mentioned the total encroached forest area to be 7,506.48 sq km — a little more than half of what has been revealed in the latest assessment. Madhya Pradesh registered the highest degree of forest encroachment with a staggering 5,460.9 sq km affected, followed by Assam. Severely impacted states include Karnataka, Maharashtra, Arunachal Pradesh, Uttar Pradesh and Jharkhand among others. What is more, this is only a partial view of the crisis as 10 states, including West Bengal, are yet to submit their data despite multiple reminders from the Centre.

Rapid urban expansion powered by a lopsided model of development that prioritises economic growth over sustainability has been increasingly putting pressure on India’s dwindling forests. The Centre’s Rs 80,000 crore mega infrastructure project on the Great Nicobar Island proposes to divert 130 sq km of tropical rainforest area. Telangana — among the states that have failed to submit forest encroachment data — was recently found to be clearing large tracts of the Kancha Gachibowli forest. That the apex court had to intervene and stay the tree-felling is an indictment of the government’s scant regard for environmental concerns. Such institutional apathy makes the protection of forest land as well as the reclaiming of encroached forests challenging. There is an additional concern. Encroachments on forest land not only disrupt an already fragile ecological balance but also threaten marginalised, forest-dependent communities whose identification and rights are recognised and protected by the Forest Rights Act, 2006. The executive must rectify this predation on precious forested land. But such interventions are contingent upon sustained public pressure, which remains as fractured as India’s forests.

Source: Telegraph, 7/04/25

Wednesday, April 02, 2025

Quote of the Day April 2, 2025

 

“Anything that makes the world more humane and more rational is progress; that's the only measuring stick we can apply to it.”
W. Lippmann
“जो कुछ भी इस विश्व को अघिक मानवीय और विवेकशील बनाता है उसे प्रगति कहते हैं; और केवल यही मापदंड हम इसके लिये अपना सकते हैं।”
डब्ल्यू. लिपमैन

“Levels and Trends in Child Mortality” Report

 The “Levels and Trends in Child Mortality” report was released recently by the United Nations Inter-agency Group for Child Mortality Estimation (UNIGME). UNIGME (United Nations Inter-agency Group for Child Mortality Estimation) is led by UNICEF, WHO, World Bank, and UN Population Division. The report is published annually with data from 195 countries.

India’s Key Achievements in Mortality Reduction

India has achieved a 70 per cent decline in the under-five mortality rate and a 61 per cent decline in the neonatal mortality rate. This positions India among the top performers globally. The reduction in stillbirths is also noteworthy, with a 60.4 per cent decrease compared to a global reduction of 37 per cent. India ranks seventh among countries with the highest reduction in stillbirths.

Health Infrastructure Enhancements

The improvements in child mortality are attributed to enhanced health coverage and infrastructure. Key initiatives include the establishment of maternity waiting homes and newborn care units. These facilities ensure better access to healthcare services for mothers and infants. The government has also focused on training skilled birth attendants, including midwives and community health workers.

Ayushman Bharat Scheme

The Ayushman Bharat scheme plays important role in these achievements. It is the world’s largest health insurance scheme, providing nearly US$5500 annual coverage per family. This scheme aims to deliver quality healthcare without financial burden. It ensures free deliveries, medications, and diagnostic support for pregnant women and infants.

Data Systems and Surveillance Improvements

India has invested in data systems and digital surveillance to monitor maternal and child health indicators. Continuous improvements in data collection support evidence-based decision-making. This strategic approach aids in identifying areas needing attention and resources.

Global Context and Challenges

Despite these achievements, challenges remain. In 2023, an estimated 4.8 million children died before age five, including 2.3 million newborns. Many of these deaths are preventable and linked to unequal access to healthcare. Factors such as socio-economic status and living conditions affect children’s survival rates.

Economic & Political Weekly: Table of Contents

 

Vol. 60, Issue No. 13, 29 Mar, 2025

Future of work

 

Is AI the route to joblessness or joyfulness? Technological de-employment is not a new phenomenon, though this time AI is entering cognitive and not only blue-collar work


Back in 1928, John Maynard Keynes spoke of the “economic possibilities of our grandchildren”. Industrial progress, he said, was a “soiled creed, black with coal dust and gunpowder”; yet he proposed that if capital equipment continued to grow at 2% a year and technical efficiency at 1%, “the standard of life in progressive countries one hundred years hence will be between four and eight times as high as it is today.” He concluded thus that the “economic problem” — the problem of having to meet basic necessities — “would be solved… within a hundred years.” In this state of “economic bliss”, 15 hours of work a week would suffice, that too because “we have been trained too long to strive and not enjoy”. Beyond that, the “age of leisure” would be a time, in his biographer’s words, “when the spontaneous, joyful attitude to life now confined to artists and free spirits was diffused throughout society as a whole.”

Fast forward 100 years. Speaking at the Artificial Intelligence Action Summit in Paris, Prime Minister Narendra Modi heralded the “dawn of the AI age”, noting that AI will create more jobs than it destroys, with unprecedented opportunities for enhanced productivity and innovation. Indeed, Bill Gates has gone so far as to portend a three-day workweek. But with up to 23% of the working population possibly facing the axe in India by 2040 according to the NITI Aayog, rising to 69% in the World Bank’s estimate, the average worker would remain circumspect despite such rosy predictions. Indeed up-skilling and re-skilling are now strategic imperatives for individuals, firms and governments to stave off impending unemployment.

So is AI the route to joblessness or joyfulness? Much would depend on the choices we make. Technological de-employment is not a new phenomenon, though this time AI is entering cognitive and not only blue-collar work. Agricultural and textile workers became redundant with mechanisation and factory automation in the 19th century and, later, as robots were introduced to assembly lines, electrical, electronics, computers, appliances and transport industries, many were left by the wayside. While living standards and the quality of life increased globally with a broad, though still imperfect, democratisation of basic necessities, debates on the future of work have not adhered to Keynes’s prophecy. The benefits of productivity gains have neither been spread evenly nor have they allowed us to become “free spirits”. Rather, as the economists, Robert and Edward Skidelsky, noted, they have generated a competitive engine of consumption-led growth fuelled by the insatiability of material desires that do not improve our well-being or make us happier in any real sense beyond a limit. Some work more to accumulate and consume more, others to make ends meet given the unequal distribution of productivity gains. Only a few find meaning in what they do. As a result, average working hours have stagnated or increased globally since the 1980s. The economic growth story makes eminent sense for those without basic necessities, but for others, the Skidelskys noted, we are up against a “dream of… riches without end”, a “Frankenstein’s monster that [has] now programmed the game of progress according to its own insane logic”. The colloquial ‘rat race’ has led many — ethicists, spiritualists and environmentalists alike — to question the moral underpinnings of the unchecked economic growth story. Keynes seemingly underestimated one important factor: the acquisitiveness of human nature.

The coming AI revolution will reanimate these questions with urgency. While it is too early to determine the precise implications of the rollout of AI, it will undoubtedly be a defining trend. With the allocation of over Rs 10,000 crore for the India-AI Mission and estimates that the AI industry can contribute up to $1.5 trillion to India’s GDP by 2030, AI adoption in sectors such as agriculture, financial services, transportation, manufacturing, energy and healthcare is already gathering steam. The potential enhanced economic output thus made possible by AI puts to us a key choice: should the gains be distributed to raise the floor universally or deepen wealth inequality and employment insecurity? While some evidence from the OECD indicates that ‘low performers’ at work stand to benefit from the use of AI training to mimic ‘high performers’, the International Monetary Fund predicts that of the 40% of jobs in emerging markets that will have a high exposure to AI, half will replace and not complement existing workers. If the past is any measure, the natural movement of economic forces will likely exacerbate the distribution of productivity gains amidst already strained levels of inequality. Tellingly, in September last year, the International Labour Organization warned of reduced labour income share amidst productivity increases led by AI and other automation-based advancements across 36 countries over the past two decades.

From the proposal for a 3.5 day workweek by the J.P. Morgan CEO, Jamie Dimon, to the call by the L&T chairperson, S.N. Subrahmanyan, for a 90-hour workweek, we must decide how we apportion the fruits of automation. Keynes himself had hoped that technology would allow us to produce what we need at a fraction of the labour — the point was to free up time for the true, non-economic ends of life. Whether we see work instrumentally — simply as a means for sustenance and wages — or as an expression of our productive energies to give meaning to our existence, the disruptive effects of these technological changes deserve careful attention. In threatening to make human labour redundant, they can either release us from the clutches of economic necessity or push us into its arms. For the fortunate, recovering the lost art of leisure, to know what to do with ourselves outside of employment, will take some time. For others, while upskilling would be imperative, securing a just distribution of the economic gains made possible by automation will be critical. Else, we would face the prospect of a leisurely ‘India’ and a toiling ‘Bharat’.

These questions are still some distance away. India’s growth story has serious obstacles to cross with 129 million Indians in extreme poverty and 55% dependent on the State for free foodgrains. Yet, they are coming.

Raag Yadava is a lawyer and an academic

Source: Telegraph, 1/04/25

In celebration of tribal festival Sarhul, link to communities’ history, politics

 

Sarhul, literally “worship of the Sal tree”, is among the most revered Adivasi festivals. It is rooted in nature worship and celebrates the symbolic union of the Sun and the Earth.



Adivasis in Jharkhand and the larger Chhotanagpur region will welcome the new year and the spring season with the Sarhul festival on Tuesday.

Nature worship

Sal trees (Shorea robusta) are venerated in Adivasi tradition. They are seen as the abode of Sarna Maa, the deity protecting the village from inclement natural forces.

Sarhul, literally “worship of the Sal tree”, is among the most revered Adivasi festivals. It is rooted in nature worship and celebrates the symbolic union of the Sun and the Earth. A male priest from the village (pahan) plays the role of the Sun, while his wife (pahen) becomes the Earth. Priest Bandhan Tigga told The Indian Express that this union is key to all life on Earth, which depends on the coming together of the Sun’s rays and the soil (Earth).

Sarhul can thus be seen as a celebration of the cycle of life itself. Only after the rituals are completed do Adivasi folk begin ploughing their fields, sowing their crop, or entering the forest to gather produce.

Three-day festival

The main rituals happen on day two of the three-day festival at Sarna Sthals. These communally protected “sacred groves” can be found near villages across Chhotanagpur, which includes Jharkhand, parts of Chhattisgarh, Odisha, and Bihar.

In the lead up, homes and Sarna Sthals are lined with triangular, red and white Sarna flags. On the first day of Sarhul, the village’s pahan, who observes a rigorous fast, fetches water for the ceremonies, houses and Sarna Sthals are cleaned, and Sal flowers gathered for rituals.

On the next day, the main rituals take place at the Sarna Sthal. The deity is presented with Sal flowers, and a rooster is sacrificed. Villagers seek prosperity, safety, and a good harvest. Holy water is then sprinkled across the village, with performances of traditional songs and dances such as Jadur, Gena and Por Jadur. Later, young men head to nearby ponds and rivers and participate in ceremonial fishing and crab-catching to gather food for the ceremonial feast.

The final day is marked by a grand community feast, in which people share handia (rice beer) and enjoy a variety of delicacies. The festival ends with the pahan’s blessings and the villagers praying.

Chhotanagpur & beyond

Sarhul has been celebrated by tribes such as the Oraon, Munda, Santal, Khadia, and Ho, with unique names for the festival and particular ways of celebrations.

Anthropologist Sarat Chandra Roy, in his seminal work Oraon Religion and Customs (1928), observed that over time, Sarhul evolved from being a hunting-centred tradition to one that revolves around agricultural processes. This, he said, reflected the evolving lifestyle of Adivasis in Chhotanagpur.

During the 19th and early 20th centuries, when tribes such as the Munda, Oraon, and Santal were sent to faraway places as indentured labour, Sarhul traveled with them. Today, the festival is celebrated in locations ranging from the tea gardens of Assam to the Andaman and Nicobar Islands, Nepal, Bangladesh, and Bhutan.

Evolution of Sarhul

In the 1960s, Adivasi leader Baba Karthik Oraon, who advocated for social justice and the preservation of tribal culture, began a Sarhul procession from Hatma to the Siram Toli Sarna Sthal in Ranchi.

In the past 60 years, festive processions have emerged as a crucial part of Sarhul, with the Siram Toli site becoming a major point of convergence for processions. This has also made Sarhul increasingly political, and an occasion to assert the Adivasi identity.

It also comes at a time when some tribes have sought to claim their distinctiveness from Hinduism. Adivasis following the Sarna faith have demanded the inclusion of a Sarna religion column in the caste census of India in the last 20 years. Several Adivasi groups affiliated with the RSS have, however, argued that Adivasis are part of Hinduism.

Geeta Shree Oraon, national women’s president of the Akhil Bharatiya Adivasi Vikas Parishad, said the slogan ‘Sarna-Sanatani Ek Hai’ (sarna and sanatanis are one) was once given by Hindu groups to emphasise common identities.

Written by Shubham Tigga

Source: Indian Express, 1/04/25